Vadodara: Amid a major political storm, heated exchanges and protests, the BJP-ruled Vadodara Municipal Corporation (VMC) on Wednesday approved by majority the proposal to allot a prime 978-sq-metre plot in Tandalja to former India cricketer and MP Yusuf Pathan, despite strong opposition from Congress councillors.The proposal, cleared unanimously by the standing committee on Oct 23, sparked an uproar in the general body, where BJP and Congress councillors traded barbs. The Congress accused the BJP-led state govt of changing its stand after Pathan extended support to the NDA.Confirming the approval, mayor Geeta Makwana said the proposal had come from the state govt. “There was some controversy because of the opposition, but since the proposal came from the state govt, we approved it by majority,” she told reporters after the meeting.On whether other cricketers seeking land would receive similar treatment, Makwana said, “If any proposal comes from the state govt, we will discuss it accordingly.” She maintained that the allotment was sanctioned according to the rules and regulations.The general body witnessed heated arguments after councillor Ashish Joshi questioned the BJP’s support for Pathan. “In my eyes, everyone supporting Yusuf Pathan is a Pathan,” he remarked, triggering an uproar. BJP councillor Ajay Dabhi retorted by calling him “Ashish Pathan”, prompting ruling party councillors to repeatedly raise slogans of “Ashish Pathan”.Joshi also asked why the BJP had rejected a proposal to pay Rs 25 lakh each to families of the 14 victims, including 12 children, who died in the Harni boat tragedy, while extending concessions on land worth over Rs 20 crore to Pathan. Congress councillors Pushpa Vaghela and Deepa Srivastava also strongly opposed the allotment.Outside the VMC headquarters, Congress workers attempting to enter the premises were stopped by police and security personnel, leading to a scuffle. Several Congress leaders, including the city Congress president, were detained and taken to Gotri police station, where party workers protested against the police action.Congress councillor Tirth Brahmbhatt arrived dressed in Pathani attire to oppose the decision. He questioned why similar consideration was not extended to Vadodara-born woman cricketer Radha Yadav, who had sought land for sports-related development. He also submitted representations seeking office space for councillors, residential plots for journalists and compensation for Harni boat tragedy victims.Senior Congress councillor Chandrakant Srivastava warned that the party would approach court if the proposal was approved.Under the approved proposal, 500 sq metres of the plot will be allotted to Pathan free of cost for residential use, while the remaining 478 sq metres will be transferred at 55% of its assessed value, offering a 45% concession. The plot’s estimated market value is Rs 20.53 crore. The state revenue department will compensate VMC with land of equivalent value for the portion allotted free.The controversy dates to 2012, when Pathan sought a 99-year lease of the plot adjoining his family residence. The state govt rejected the proposal in 2014, citing the need for public auction or open bidding. VMC subsequently alleged encroachment and issued Pathan a notice in 2024.Gujarat High Court upheld the rejection in Aug 2025, ruling that prolonged possession conferred no legal rights. Pathan unconditionally withdrew his appeal on Aug 31, 2026.The allotment also drew objections from Vishwamitri Bachao Samiti, which argued that it was contrary to the provisions and spirit of the Disturbed Areas Act. Gujarat Congress president Amit Chavda separately accused the state govt of double standards.
