Gurgaon: MCG’s decision to make satisfaction certificates from ward councillors mandatory for releasing payments to contractors has not gone down well with residents. The move reinforces an existing system that has failed to improve civic conditions “on the ground”, they have argued. They said empowering councillors with “greater control over the process” had not translated into better civic services or improved accountability. “MCG should work for public interest, not to satisfy someone’s ego,” convener of citizens’ group United Gurgaon RWA (UGR) Parveen Yadav told TOI. Sector 9A resident Lalit Suraj Bhola asked, “Why reward a failed system with more power instead of introducing transparency and accountability?”MCG’s latest order requires councillors to submit certificates confirming the satisfactory completion of specified civic works before contractors’ payments can be processed. UGR co-convener Chaitali Mandhotra told TOI on Thursday, “RWAs should be formally incorporated into the monitoring and verification mechanism. People living in an area are directly affected by the quality of roads, drainage, sewerage, horticulture and sanitation services and can provide a more realistic assessment of whether the work has actually been completed as promised.”MCG officials said that the move is aimed at strengthening monitoring and ensuring that public money is released only against work completed on the ground. “The practice was already in place and we have just reiterated it,” said an MCG official, privy to the matter. However, residents believe that the exercise risks becoming a procedural formality unless the monitoring mechanism is broadened to include RWAs and other stakeholders who can independently verify the quality of civic works.Reacting to the civic body’s order, residents said that despite giving elected representatives a greater say in monitoring civic works, the city continued to grapple with poor infrastructure, inadequate sanitation and substandard execution of development projects. Instead of relying exclusively on councillors’ satisfaction certificates, the civic body should involve RWAs, which are better positioned to assess the quality of work and identify deficiencies at the neighbourhood level.They also stressed that merely introducing another layer of approval would not address the city’s civic problems unless there was independent verification of works, transparency in payments and accountability for poor-quality execution. “The point to ponder if the people of the ward are not satisfied with the work done by MCG then what is the significance of satisfaction letter of that particular ward councillor. MCG should work for public interest, not to satisfy someone’s ego,” said Parveen Yadav, convener of UGR.Bhola of sector 9A said, “MCG was already making contractor payments based on councillors’ satisfaction letters and as a result sanitation and civic conditions have only gone from bad to worse. So why is MCG doubling down on this failed system? If the MCG is serious about changing the city, involve RWAs — the actual end users — in monitoring and certifying work.”Councillors maintain that their satisfaction certificates are essential to ensure accountability among contractors, prevent payments for incomplete or substandard works and make elected representatives answerable for the quality of civic development in their wards. “We have been elected by the citizens to work for them and betterment of the city. Each councillor in their respective wards know about its problems and are directly connected with the citizens. We ensure that the works are done before the payments are released,” said ward 11 councillor Kuldeep Yadav. “We have no problem if MCG also makes satisfaction letters from the RWAs mandatory besides the councillors. It will add one more layer of check and monitoring,” he added.
