Hundreds of Google employees have signed a petition asking the company to give schools a version of Google Search without generative AI. The appeal comes as three of the largest US school districts weigh switching search engines, according to The New York Times. The issue is whether schools can turn off AI for students and still let them look things up on Google.The dispute began earlier this month when Google’s vice president for education, Chris Phillips, told the Times that Search and AI were “deeply integrated”. He said students attempting to use Search at schools that ban AI would see a message saying the service was unavailable. Some districts, including New York City, have already restricted student-facing generative AI over concerns about how it affects learning.New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani accused Google of using its market power to push AI into public schools. In Chicago, parents, teachers and students protested outside a Google office. The Times subsequently reported that New York City, Los Angeles and Chicago were all considering alternative search engines.
What Google workers are asking for
The Alphabet Workers Union’s petition, titled “Let Students Search”, is addressed to Phillips, Google CEO Sundar Pichai and Search chief Elizabeth Hamon Reid. The union argues that educators should decide when students use AI and that taking away Search could prompt districts to drop other Google products. It also warned that losing school district business could affect job security.“The decision of how and when to implement AI into a classroom belongs to the educators leading it,” Parul Koul, the union’s president and a Google software engineer, said in a statement.
Can schools turn off AI inside Search
Google has said that under changes expected early next year, schools will be able to enable or disable Search, Gemini and NotebookLM individually. That means a school could switch off the standalone Gemini chatbot and keep Search available to students. Google’s clarification left open whether schools could also disable the generative AI features that appear within Search itself.The union said some coverage had made it sound as though Google was deliberately punishing schools for opting out of AI. Its petition asks for a setting that would let schools apply their classroom AI policies to Search while keeping the search engine available for everyday use.
