HC quashes Gangsters Act FIR, issues binding guidelines for future cases | Prayagraj News


HC quashes Gangsters Act FIR, issues binding guidelines for future cases

Prayagraj: While quashing a Gangsters Act FIR in the Saharanpur liquor case, the Allahabad high court on Thursday described the act as an exception to the ordinary criminal process and not an alternative to it. Accordingly, the court issued certain binding directions for future cases, stating that action under the act requires an individual assessment of each accused.It further directed that reasons must be recorded where the base case is already pending trial, the status of related proceedings must be fully disclosed, proper minutes of joint meetings must be maintained, and specific justification must be provided before a public servant is included.Allowing a writ petition, a division bench of Justice Chandra Dhari Singh and Justice Tarun Saxena quashed the FIR registered by the Saharanpur Police in connection with the 2021 country liquor excise evasion case.The court set aside the dated Dec 12, 2025, the gang chart and all consequential proceedings against the accused — Pranay Aneja, Ashwani Upadhyay, Upendra Govind Rao and Ravindra Kishor — all petitioners in the present writ petition.The FIR was based on a single incident from March 2021, which is already being tried in Lucknow, where 10 charge sheets have been filed and all the accused are on bail.The court held that the Gangsters Act remains operative, since the Supreme Court, in the Shiv Pratap Singh case, had left its constitutional validity open. Nevertheless, the FIR failed on two independent grounds. First, it alleged no violence, threat or coercion, and nothing was alleged against any of the petitioners in the nearly five years following the incident, the court added.The court further said that, in the present case, the Gangsters Act was invoked only after the state lost the licence litigation, and 20 names were added to the special investigation team’s (SIT) list of nine without any reason. Secondly, the gang chart was approved mechanically, with identical and undated endorsements, no minutes of the joint meeting and only a recorded consensus.However, the court clarified that the trial in the present case before the Special Judge, PC Act, CBI (central), Lucknow, as well as the proceedings under the Prevention of Money Laundering Act (PMLA) and the departmental proceedings, would continue unaffected.The court directed the registrar (compliance) to forward a copy of the judgment to the chief secretary and the additional chief secretary (home), Government of Uttar Pradesh, within two weeks. The copy shall be circulated to all district magistrates, commissioners of police and senior superintendents of police/superintendents of police in the state.



Source link

About The Author

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *