Consumer panel rejects repair-only warranty, orders refund for defective sandals | Gurgaon News


Consumer panel rejects repair-only warranty, orders refund for defective sandals
The panel also noted that the company had produced no evidence to rebut the complainants’ allegations

Gurgaon: The district consumer commission has rejected a footwear company’s repair-only warranty policy and ordered it to refund the price of a pair of sandals that developed a defect on first use. It also directed the company to pay Rs 26,000 in compensation and litigation costs.It directed Stelatoes Shoes & Accessories Pvt Ltd to refund Rs 2,429 with 9% annual interest from Aug 30, 2025, Rs 15,000 for mental harassment and Rs 11,000 towards litigation expenses.Deepak Gupta and his wife Shweta had bought the sandals for Rs 2,429 from the company’s Gurdwara Road showroom on Aug 30, 2025. The salesperson allegedly assured them that the footwear was a fresh piece and carried a six-month replacement warranty in case of any defect.When Shweta wore the sandals for the first time on Sept 1, the heel bent and the adhesive came loose, the couple alleged. They returned to the showroom on Sept 3, but the manager allegedly blamed the damage on her twisting her foot and refused a replacement, offering only repairs. Their repeated requests for a refund went unanswered, after which they approached the commission.Advocate Chandan Yadav, representing the complainants, relied on their affidavit, the purchase invoice and photographs of the sandals. The company’s authorised representative, Akshay Sharma, argued that the terms printed on the invoice excluded refunds and allowed only repairs within a 90-day warranty period. He said the company was willing to repair the footwear.The commission, headed by president Sanjeev Jindal with members Jyoti Siwach and Khushwinder Kaur, rejected the defence. It observed that a company could not benefit from its own wrongdoing after selling poor-quality goods, and held that unilateral warranty conditions placing consumers at a disadvantage could not override their rights.The panel also noted that the company had produced no evidence to rebut the complainants’ allegations. Holding that the company had committed deficiency in service and adopted an unfair trade practice, it allowed the complaint.



Source link

About The Author

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *