Gurgaon: A private university cannot automatically withhold information about its establishment, functioning and regulatory compliance by claiming it falls outside the Right to Information (RTI) Act, Haryana State Information Commission (SIC) has ruled.The commission has directed Directorate General of Higher Education (DGHE), Panchkula, to examine its records on city-based Sushant University and obtain information from the university wherever the department has the legal authority to do so. The information must be given to the applicant free of cost within a month of receiving the order.The order, passed by state information commissioner Dr Ajay Kumar Sura on Oct 22, came on an appeal by Yashwant Kumar. He had filed an RTI application on April 29, 2019, seeking details about the university, formerly known as Ansal University, but said the information was not furnished despite considerable time. He filed his first appeal on Jan 11, 2022, and a second appeal before the commission on April 11, 2022. The matter was heard in compliance with an earlier commission order dated Aug 20, 2025.During the hearing, the university’s representative argued that Sushant University was a private, self-financed institution and not a public authority under Section 2(h) of the RTI Act, as it was neither owned, controlled nor substantially financed by the central or state govt. The representative also cited a June 12, 2023 communication from vice-chancellor Prof Sanjeev Kumar Sharma, which had told the applicant that the institution did not fall within the purview of the Act.The commission held that private status alone was not sufficient ground to deny information. Even if a private institution is not directly covered by the Act, it said, information relating to it can be accessed through a govt authority that has the legal power to obtain such records under another law. Citing Sections 2(f) and 2(j), the commission noted that the Act’s definition of information also covers records of private bodies that public authorities can legally access.The applicant’s questions covered when and under which legislation the university was established, the orders under which it came into existence, and who its chancellor is and which authority appoints the incumbent. He also sought details of students admitted under Haryana domicile categories since the university’s establishment, and the number who received fee concessions, with corresponding figures; the total number of physically and mentally disabled students admitted since then, and the facilities and provisions available to them under govt rules; copies of orders and guidelines issued to the university by University Grants Commission, govt and other regulators, and whether the university complied with them, along with certified copies of compliance reports submitted to regulatory authorities.Identifying DGHE Haryana as the state’s regulatory authority for higher education, the commission observed that the department may have access to records on the university’s establishment, recognition, functioning and compliance, subject to powers under applicable laws and regulations.It directed the SPIO-cum-assistant director in the DGHE office to examine each question individually, verify records available with or under the control of the department, and determine what additional information can legally be obtained from the university. The officer must also check information already supplied and correct deficiencies, replacing incomplete, blank or illegible pages with complete, readable copies and providing certified copies of official records wherever sought.If particular information is neither available with the department nor legally obtainable from the university, the applicant must be informed specifically, with reasons. The department will not have to generate fresh information or provide explanations that are not part of existing records.The commission has fixed the next hearing for Dec 7, 2026, at 11 am, and directed both parties to appear in person to report compliance. A copy of the order has been sent to DGHE Haryana for necessary action.It referred to Delhi High Court’s judgment in Telecom Regulatory Authority of India v Kabir Shankar Bose (2018), which recognised that a public authority must obtain information from a private body and provide it under the RTI Act where it has the requisite legal entitlement. It also cited Supreme Court’s observations in CPIO, Supreme Court of India v Subhash Chandra Agarwal (2020) and CBSE v Aditya Bandopadhyay (2011), which stress transparency but clarify that authorities need not create fresh information, opinions or explanations that do not exist in official records.
